These “ice box” cookies were mom’s favorite, even though we kids didn’t think they had much flavor. Yet when I took them into the Times Leader Taste Testers, the reviews were almost all very positive.

Icebox cakes are simple, no-bake desserts perfect for summer. They are made with a ladyfinger or cookie crust and a pudding or custard filling, and are chilled in the freezer so that the layers soften ...